Fall 2000

Agricultural Health: info for health care providers

Animal Injuries are a Serious Problem

by Kelley J. Donham

 

During the last two months there have been at least two serious cases involving animals. One of the cases resulted in two fatalities. The first case involved a farmer who was trying to get the cattle back in from a freshly picked cornfield.  He felt that, as the cattle had not been used to eating corn, they may suffer from laminitis (founder, a condition of overeating affecting the hoof wall) if they were out there too long. In attempting to get the cattle in, he got between a calf and its mother. The cow decided it was going to get to the calf, and blitzed the would be drover, knocking him to the ground, resulting in multiple fractured ribs, and internal as well as external contusions (bruising). He got up, got to his pickup, and somehow got to the hospital. He was in serious condition, in intensive care and on a respirator for nearly two weeks. He is now home, and should recover fully over the next three to four months. He is 65 years old.

 

During the first week of October, one of three brothers lay in a hospital in Northeast Iowa, suffering from a severe mauling by a young Angus bull. He had been trying to move the bull from an open lot, to a smaller pen in the barn. The bull decided differently, and proceeded to knock the man down causing numerous internal injuries and a compound fracture of his tibia and fibula. While in the hospital being treated, he was worried by the fact that his two brothers that he farmed with had not been up to the hospital to see him. He contacted relatives, who went out to the farm and found the bodies of his two brothers in the pen with the bull, who had killed them both. The two deceased brothers were 79 and 84.

 

A few years back, a dairy farmer near North Liberty was moving his Holstein bull to a new pen.  The bull again decided that was not what he wanted, and proceeded to knock the man down, and pummeled him into the ground. He was able to get away, but was having extreme difficulty breathing. Although he was the only person home, he somehow managed to get himself to the hospital. They diagnosed “flail chest” which means all of his ribs were broken, making it nearly impossible to breathe. They put him on a respirator, and he managed a slow recovery over the next year. That dairy farm went out of business at the end of that year, because the owners injuries caused disabilities that kept him from doing the work necessary to keep up the operation. The owner was 56 years old at the time.

 

These cases represent several facts and implications about agricultural injuries that should be recognized. Injuries are often studied by the three main parameters that may have resulted in the injuries (human factors, agent factors, and environmental factors). After each category below, write what you think a response might be, then look forward to see if we have some ideas and thoughts in common in this case.

 

Questions:

 

  1. How do statistics of animal–related injuries compare to machinery - related injuries in agriculture?

 

  1. What specific human factors may have been contributory to these cases?

 

  1. What specific animal–related factors may have contributed to these injuries?

 

  1. What specific environmental conditions may have contributed to these injuries?

 

  1. What specific rescue and medical complications might be considered in these situations?

 

  1. What are some specific prevention recommendations?

 

 

Answers to case study